Let's review:
Don't get me wrong, it's nice to see the Mariners hitting a little bit, but come on - they were up against a garbage pitcher, so I'd be upset if they didn't eek out six or seven runs. What's discouraging is that the offense always seems to have to dig the team out of a hole after the starter blows up early. Jamie Moyer's the only member of the current rotation whose ERA is below the league average, and that's only by 0.04 points pitching in front of a good defense in a pitcher-friendly environment. Put another way, this team isn't a good starter away from competing - it's four good starters away from competing, and with the in-house options dropping like flies and the external options quite limited (at least, as far as the upcoming FA market is concerned), I don't know how much improvement we can realistically expect to see in 2006. Sure, there's Felix (KNOCK ON WOOD! KNOCK ON WOOD!!), an old Moyer, and whatever's left of Bobby Madritsch, but there's not really anything behind them, and Matsuzaka (probable Japanese import), if we get him, is still only one guy. We're pretty much a red-hot Adrian Beltre away from turning into the 2000-2003 Texas Rangers.
Biggest Contribution: Adrian Beltre, +45.7%
Biggest Suckfest: Gil Meche, -40.8%
Most Important Hit: Beltre homer, +27.8%
Most Important Pitch: Rodriguez double, -14.1%
Total Contribution by Pitcher(s): -50.2%
Total Contribution by Hitters: +2.3%
The lineup just about broke even on the game, but it's hard to pick up a real high rating when you're always coming from behind. And hey, kudos to the pitching staff for keeping the defecit intact despite the strongest of threats. Momentum? Not on their watch. The Mariners were down to about a one-in-nine chance of winning after the first inning, which is bad enough, but after Beltre made a game of it with a three-run homer, Meche and Nageotte imploded in the fifth and left the team with a 1.3% chance of victory. What's a good antonym for "timely pitching"?
Allow me to paint a grisly picture for you. What follows is a list of starting rotation candidates we've had this year, along with each player's current status:
Jamie Moyer (Pitching reasonably well, bad back)
Joel Pineiro (Tanked, looks to have a trick elbow)
Gil Meche (Tanked, bad shoulder)
Ryan Franklin (Standard performance, suspended, may not return to team in any capacity)
Aaron Sele (Terrible, released)
Bobby Madritsch (Bad shoulder, likely gone for year)
Ron Villone (Became a LOOGY, traded)
Julio Mateo (Not a viable starter, now middle relief)
Matt Thornton (Please God, no)
Cha Baek (Tanked in AAA, probable injury)
Jorge Campillo (Bad elbow, gone for year)
Jeff Harris (Nothing special, zero experience)
Felix Hernandez (KNOCK ON WOOD! KNOCK ON WOOD!!)
Bobby Livingston (Too young, almost zero experience in AAA)
Andrew Lorraine (Sucks)
Damian Moss (Sucks)
Travis Blackley (Trick shoulder, gone for year)
Clint Nageotte (Converted to relief)
Rafael Soriano (Rehabbing, still relief)
How do you build an August rotation out of those 19 guys? Presumably, it will look something like (in no particular order) Moyer/Meche/Piniero/Hernandez/Harris for the time being, but two of those guys are almost certainly pitching hurt, so even the possible return of Ryan Franklin leaves us with a trouble spot if and when the pain gets worse. I don't really know how they're going to handle this, nor am I all that excited to find out. That's just...that's really bad, even with Felix.
After throwing 104 pitches in 4.2 crappy innings of work, Gil Meche's ERA stands at 5.04, his OPS against at .811, and his average number of pitchers per inning at 18.0, tied for second-worst in the Majors. You'd like to think that maybe, just maybe, he's throwing a lot of pitches because he gets a lot of strikeouts, but his K rate ranks 66th among 106 qualified starters. Everything - everything about Meche has gotten worse this year, except for the win total, which would probably be enough to earn him a substantial raise in arbitration, if the Mariners take him that far.
Conclusion? Gil Meche is a bad pitcher. A bad pitcher with no more potential for success than any other bad pitcher in the league, really, so it's time to stop playing make-believe. He'd be replaced in the rotation by a team with a little more starting depth, but given our current situation, he's just going to find himself back out there every five days, nibbling around the corners and getting hammered when he comes over the plate. Occasionally he'll throw a sharp curve that freezes a hitter, but that's all he does well, and he doesn't even do it that often. Give up. Gil Meche needs to be somewhere else next March, because if he's not, something's gone horribly awry.
Mound conference, bottom five:
Price: "Gil, Gil, Gil..."
Meche: "I know, I know..."
Price: "You suck."
Meche: "What?"
Price: "You suck. You are not a good pitcher."
Meche: "Yes, I am..."
Betancourt: "You, Gil Meche, are the suck."
Meche: "You speak English?"
Sexson: "I taught him that."
Beltre: "He's right, too."
Gonzalez: "Agreed."
Meche: "Wh-...Willie? Whose side are you on?"
Bloomquist: "Theirs. You suck-diddly-uck."
Price: "Hand me the ball, assbag."
I was getting the Detroit feed over MLB.tv and, as such, got to see a lot of the local commercials. One of the ads was for a store called Bell Tire, a spot during which a guy read down a list of services offered at the place, and a little animated mascot in the background would say "Bell Tire!" after each line. I have to say, the words "Bell Tire" began to lose their meaning quickly, as I was just hearing it over and over again in rapid sequence. Before long it began to sound like "belt higher", then suddenly my mind just went blank altogether, and I lost focus on what I was listening to. This strikes me as a rather suboptimal marketing strategy, given that by the end of the spot, I didn't even remember what was being advertised. It's kind of like how, if you keep saying "frog" to yourself, eventually you forget what word it is you're actually saying and you think about how silly-sounding it is coming out of your mouth. I guess that's why "Bell Tire" hasn't gone national.
Yuniesky Betancourt's many tools on display:
Contact hitting. Just one strikeout in first 23 plate appearances.
Dash of power. Two doubles, a triple, and a ball to the track so far.
Speed. Legged out a triple in his first Major League AB.
Arm. Fired a strike to first after barehanding a ball that deflected off of Beltre yesterday.
Glove. Hasn't botched any simple plays yet, and seems to have soft hands.
Range. Fielded a Chris Shelton groundball on the first-base side of second today in the bottom of the fifth.
A little plate discipline spike and we could be talking about one hell of a player, here.
Since June 29th (I know, arbitrary start point), Adrian Beltre has nine home runs in 122 at bats, for a ratio of one per 13.6. Last year, he hit one per 12.5 AB's. Over a full season of 600 at bats (about what he did in 2004), that's a difference of just four longballs. The power was not a fluke.
The moment we've all been waiting for will come tomorrow morning somewhere around 10:15, when Felix Hernandez (KNOCK ON WOOD! KNOCK ON WOOD!!) takes the hill for the first time in what should be a long, successful Major League career (KNOCK ON WOOD! KNOCK ON WOOD!!). Even though the game isn't on TV in Seattle, MLB.tv will still be picking it up with the stadium closed circuit camera feed, at the very least. So, if you're an out-of-market fan, I suggest paying the $3.95 it costs to use MLB.tv for a day, if you aren't already a subscriber. No matter what happens, it will be worth it.
Light a candle for Felix. It's out of our hands.
0 recs | 14 comments
That mound conference bit was hilarious
I can definitly see Willie being a Flanders.My computer desk id wooden and I'll be knocking on it from the time I get up till the time the game starts tommorow.
Goose - August 3, 2005
Seconded
Best mound conference ever. If only the infield and Price were that cool.Gomez - August 3, 2005
Whoever
Scouted Yuniesky Betancourt should never, ever, ever, ever, ever, ever, ever, ever, ever, infinity-ever+1 leave this organization.JLC - August 3, 2005
Yeh, this kid is gonna be good
He's already my favorite rookie.Goose - August 3, 2005
Man I am amped...
for tomorrow's radio broadcast.PLU Tim - August 3, 2005
Just for clarification...
Persons who live in seattle cannot watch this game on mlbtv?Kirk Hammett - August 3, 2005
Not unless you find a loophole somehow.
Jeff Sullivan - August 4, 2005
There's a loop hole
If you go the the UW, you can watch MLB.TV in campus, and they aren't part of the blackout restriction.BeltredNOT - August 4, 2005
tomorrow
King Felix: Our only rey of hope.Steve Nelson - August 3, 2005
Price: "Hand me the ball, assbag."
U.S.S Mariner is trying to cut back on Mariers-related swearing... you're making it into an art-form... Way to go, Jeff.jameslcrockett - August 4, 2005
I'm a very happy man I live in NY
MLB.TV NO BLACKOUT!!Oh, and I really really like Betancourt. I remember posting on U.S.S. a couple months ago how I thought he could be the SS of the next couple years for the M's and the guys over there laughed in my face. Let's see who is laughing now. His defense is sick.
phil333 - August 4, 2005
The Pitching
Jeff,I agree with your overall assessment of the M's pitching problems. However, I still don't think that it is quite as bad as you make it out to be.
I will go back through your list with a bit more optimistic view:
Jamie Moyer (Pitching reasonably well, bad back)
-I think that the M's should offer Moyer arbitration, then let him walk to another team. The M's could use the extra picks. However, the M's need to build for 2006-2008. Jaime is not in that picture.
Joel Pineiro (Tanked, looks to have a trick elbow)
-true
Gil Meche (Tanked, bad shoulder)
-true
Ryan Franklin (Standard performance, suspended, may not return to team in any capacity)
-I hope you are right about him. I just don't like Franklin. Too much complaining about runs and all.
Aaron Sele (Terrible, released)
-can't argue here
Bobby Madritsch (Bad shoulder, likely gone for year)
-how Madritsch is when he comes back is huge. He should be throwing by the end of the season (hopefully) and the M's should get a better idea of where he is. His injury is strange, so this is a big question mark. However, if he comes back OK, it would be huge for the M's.
Ron Villone (Became a LOOGY, traded)
-see Sele
Julio Mateo (Not a viable starter, now middle relief)
-true
Matt Thornton (Please God, no)
-yup
Cha Baek (Tanked in AAA, probable injury)
-not an option
Jorge Campillo (Bad elbow, gone for year)
-not an option
Jeff Harris (Nothing special, zero experience)
-true
Felix Hernandez (KNOCK ON WOOD! KNOCK ON WOOD!!)
-he'll be in the rotation for sure unless the worst happens
Bobby Livingston (Too young, almost zero experience in AAA)
-yeah, but could show up in Seattle late next season.
Andrew Lorraine (Sucks)
Damian Moss (Sucks)
-true x2
Travis Blackley (Trick shoulder, gone for year)
-no way we can realistically expect him to pitch for the M's next year
Clint Nageotte (Converted to relief)
-the M's might have to consider moving him back to the rotation. He could be a viable option
Rafael Soriano (Rehabbing, still relief)
-the M's might have to consider letting him start as well. Not much talk about this, but he used to be a pretty good starter. Obviously, not what you want them to count on. But he could be good.
-you forgot one important person: Jesse Foppert. He could very likely be in the rotation in 2006 out of spring training. He will be well removed from TJ surgery, and his command should be improved.
Thus, the M's real options are Meche, Piniero, Madritsch, Felix, Nageotte, and Foppert. That is not a real deep pool of talent. However, lets just hope that one of Meche or Pineiro are able to be a decent back of the rotation guy. Felix is in for sure. Madritsch is a big question mark, and lets hope for the best. Foppert is a legit option as well, and he could be the pleasant surprise of 2006. Lets hope so.
Where does that leave the M's? They will need to add at least two arms, minimum.
However, one thing that the M's do have at their disposal is $$$. Since they moved Winn and Villone, and have Moyer, Boone, Shiggy, the Cirillo $$$, Wiki, and a few others coming off the books, the M's will have some cash to work with. They could realistically sign two guys to ~$10 mil/year contracts. This free agent class isn't strong, but there are guys like AJ Burnett, Brad Penny, and hopefully Daisuke Matsuzaka out there. The M's will also have to look into a trade. Who knows who might be available, but I don't think that people foresaw Mulder or Hudson moving last year. The M's have some prospects and can take on some salary. Perhaps they could take a chance on someone like Kerry Wood, if he should become available. Who knows.
The point is, if the M's went out and throw money at this problem, which they have the resources to do, they could go sign two guys like Burnett and Matsuzaka. That would give them a rotation of Burnett, Matsuzaka, Felix, and two from the group of Madritsch, Meche, Pineiro, Foppert, ect. That is not too bad. I would think that two of those guys would rise to the occasion. Bringing back Franklin as insurance might not be such a bad idea. However, the situation isn't as bad as a lot of the bloggers make it out to be.
The one good thing about this season is that the lineup is pretty much set. The M's could go into 2006 with this lineup:
Ichiro RF
Reed CF
Ibanez DH
Sexson 1B
Beltre 3B
Snelling LF
Lopez 2B
Betancourt/Morse SS
Torrealba C
and they wouldn't be looking too bad. Adding a cheap alternative at C might not be a bad move. But this team would be servicable. Adding a lefty hitter with power in LF might not be a bad move. However, the M's could just keep their fingers with Snelling, with Choo as Plan B. Luckily, if those two bomb, LF is the easiest place to add production.
If they just throw cash at the pitching problem, the M's COULD be a decent team in 2006. Probably not a contender yet, but much better than this year.
Jerry - August 4, 2005
Nice post
Well thought out post, Jerry. I still, however, found the mound conference hilarious.Gomez - August 4, 2005
I agree on the mound conference
I was crying with laughter while reading that. The Betancourt bit was my favorite.I like your optimism, Jerry. Good post.
nosretap - August 5, 2005
You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Lookout Landing to post a comment.