Well I wasn't really expecting this:
Hearing that Adam Moore will be called up tomorrow. Rob Johnson to Tacoma.
Granted, this'll only last for a month, if that, but if I'm interpreting this correctly, it's a pretty big statement. It also explains why Josh Bard has caught two of Felix's last three starts. Bard caught on July 20th, then caught Felix on July 21st. Bard also caught on July 30th, then caught Felix on July 31st. Unless Johnson was dealing with something minor that didn't leak to the media, the Mariners made the deliberate decision to have him sit out a couple Felix Days. That's significant.
I forgot who it was that pointed out that the Mariners haven't spoken as glowingly of Johnson this year as they did in 2009, but it seems to be true, and this may be the latest indication that they're growing increasingly frustrated. Johnson's sitting on a .574 OPS, and while his throwing arm has been okay, he leads the league in passed balls and has allowed an additional 23 wild pitches. Almost everything about Johnson has been a disappointment this year - even his walk rate, which has dropped to 7.6% since early May after an encouraging start. Pitchers figured out how bad he is, just as they did ages ago with Jack Wilson.
Is Adam Moore the savior? Doubt it. He's had his defensive problems, too. He looked like total crap with Seattle before he got hurt. He has hit fairly well with Tacoma, though, with a double and a homer just yesterday, so, what the hell? What's the harm? Moore gets a confidence boost from having earned another chance, and Rob Johnson learns that he can't just rest on his reputation. His reputation has changed a little bit.
I could be making entirely too much of one simple, short-term transaction, but: Rob Johnson had a shot to be the Mariners' catcher of the future. He couldn't take advantage, so now it looks like he'll have to wait his turn for seconds while Moore gets a go. I don't think anybody sees Moore as some future superstar, but I also don't think anybody wanted him to stay trapped behind Johnson without ever getting a chance. He is at least as talented. Time for him to show that he might have a little bit more.

If Michael Pineda falls in love with Rob Johnson, I quit.
0 recs | 137 comments
Moore won't be a superstar,
but he at least has a chance to be league average, which would be saying something for the M’s.
Thingray - August 2, 2010
Yell at me if I thinking to crazily, but could Rob Johnson be in AAA just to catch Pineda?
Mariner Melee - August 2, 2010
too*
Mariner Melee - August 2, 2010
THIS IS ME YELLING AT YOU
wyte_lightning - August 2, 2010
Well its in all caps so I assumed as much.
Mariner Melee - August 2, 2010
BLAAARRRRRGGGHHHHH NOOOOOO!
(I hope the yelling tone came across well) (I hope you’re thinking crazily, really.)
seattlesundevil - August 2, 2010
They want to give Moore a shot, and Johnson has options left.
I’m going to assume it’s that simple until something shows me differently.
Thingray - August 2, 2010
Pineda hasn't had much practice at overcoming wild pitches
I’m sure Rob can teach him a thing or two.
skjes - August 2, 2010 via mobile
For the first time in weeks I actually just experienced some emotion about this team
royalcurve - August 2, 2010
I forgot we had a team.
Teej - August 2, 2010
Well, you and I do
apparently, they are good
seattlebruin - August 2, 2010
I am being talked into being a Giants fan because I think it's funny when the pitchers hit and hey, Buster Posey!
seattlebruin - August 2, 2010
I agree with this
Marinerfanjake - August 2, 2010
Travis Ishikawa has a Japanese name
seattlebruin - August 2, 2010
Turd Ferguson has a funny name.
Thingray - August 2, 2010
And is from Seattle.
abender20 - August 2, 2010
That's Tim Lincecum you're thinking of
seattlebruin - August 2, 2010
Never heard of him but he sounds like a queer.
abender20 - August 2, 2010
Nah, queers have better haircuts.
JY - August 2, 2010
Or at least more highlights.
Thingray - August 2, 2010
He's a goddamn hippie!
Drew_D - August 2, 2010
Makes sense because he got arrested with maryjane, but why was that not made much more public?
jbpalm - August 2, 2010
Federal Way, I think.
JY - August 2, 2010
Renton
Marinerfanjake - August 2, 2010
HS in Federal Way
Hit it, B-Ref
JY - August 2, 2010
Rendon
abender20 - August 2, 2010
The Giants are my NL team.
SeaKoala - August 2, 2010
I live in a National League city that is not San Francisco
seattlebruin - August 2, 2010
I don't live in San Francisco, but some of my family is from the San Francisco area.
Plus they’re good. And one of their team colors is orange. I like the color orange.
SeaKoala - August 2, 2010
Closet Orioles fan...
Thingray - August 2, 2010
I'm so very sorry
for you and your closet.
Paul AB - August 2, 2010
I haven't watched more than 2 innings since May
royalcurve - August 2, 2010
I still enjoy reading Matthew's report cards though
royalcurve - August 2, 2010
:O
royalcurve - August 2, 2010
Neato!
ThundaPC - August 2, 2010
Best news Ive heard all week
even though the season has been in the tank since the end of April, its comforting to see some of the prospects getting their hacks in, whether they succeed or not. Pineda and Ackley next?
E2ESQUARE - August 2, 2010
Please can we not call Michael Pineda up just yet
seattlebruin - August 2, 2010
I don't mind if Ackely, Pineda, etc get a cup of joe in September.
But I don’t want them called up now and starting everyday (or every five days). Let them do what they need to do in AAA, and see where we are in ST next year.
Thingray - August 2, 2010
Let them get through the playoffs with Tacoma and then get token appearances at the end of September.
JY - August 2, 2010
Exactly.
Let them at least enjoy the playoffs, it might be the last time they see them for a while.
Thingray - August 2, 2010
Z is on record saying "Ackley end it in Triple A"
But his full statement is kind of ambiguous.
Brian Floyd - August 2, 2010
I think he was talking about how impressive it was to be drafted and work your way up to AAA in one year.
MT Olson - August 2, 2010
Here's the full quote
I thought it meant AAA was the end of the line for him this year, but it could be that.
Brian Floyd - August 2, 2010
Or he will end his professional baseball career in AAA
d0nkey - August 2, 2010
Apparently Z is going to murder him after the last game of the AAA season?
Just for fun I guess?
Thingray - August 2, 2010
Why not at this point?
GO MARINERS!
d0nkey - August 2, 2010
People really need to stop misusing this quote, that's not what he was saying at all.
Jeff Nye - August 2, 2010
"and he is going to end it in Triple-A"
I know it’s not exactly what he meant, but the quote does lend itself to misinterpretation.
Thingray - August 2, 2010
It's not very well worded, I'll admit.
But if you’re reading that outside of the context of an organization that has rushed prospects in the past, it’s pretty clear that the meaning is “it’s impressive that this kid has gotten as far as AAA in his first pro season.”
Jeff Nye - August 2, 2010
Agreed.
That’s why I hate quotes sometimes.
Thingray - August 2, 2010
YES YES YES GOD YES
Poochie - August 2, 2010
WHO IS STILL WEARING PANTS
Poochie - August 2, 2010
NOT THIS GUY
Smegmalicious - August 2, 2010
PANTS ARE OFF AND WE ARE AT FAP FACTOR 5
OlSalty - August 2, 2010
FAP FAP FAP FAP FAP
wyte_lightning - August 2, 2010
I am in a public place :(
JY - August 2, 2010
Hasn't stopped me before :D
beastwarking - August 2, 2010
I am at my grandparent's house.
MT Olson - August 2, 2010
So I most definitely am.
MT Olson - August 2, 2010
FUCK IT
MT Olson - August 2, 2010
HELLO GRANDMA!!!
Thingray - August 2, 2010
With dementia setting in, who's to say what really happened?
JY - August 2, 2010
Hope Grandma left her dentures out.
Thingray - August 2, 2010
DING DONG
OlSalty - August 2, 2010
I share whatever opinion Matthew has on this transaction
Dewey N - August 2, 2010
After much thought I will mildly disagree with whatever Dave says
Poochie - August 2, 2010
Via text:
Jeff Sullivan - August 2, 2010
That is not really an opinion
Jeff Sullivan - August 2, 2010
I really need to find out how I feel about this
Dewey N - August 2, 2010
I think he feels all right
Jeff Sullivan - August 2, 2010
Via text:
Dewey N - August 2, 2010
Well that helped nothing
Dewey N - August 2, 2010
How surprising
Jeff Sullivan - August 2, 2010
Today seems to be full of surprises
Dewey N - August 2, 2010
Somewhat pleasing surprises
fluffylamps - August 2, 2010
I hope Moore grabs this opportunity by the balls.
CapSea - August 2, 2010
I hope Moore can catch some balls.
Thingray - August 2, 2010
I kind of miss Joh
fluffylamps - August 2, 2010
I was hoping for a Moore demonstrative statement from you
seattlebruin - August 2, 2010
I forgot the password to my "I Lick Squirrels" account.
CapSea - August 2, 2010
I'm Adamed if I do and I'm Adamed if I don't.
CapSea - August 2, 2010
Quick, someone register "I'm NOT Johnson."
CapSea - August 2, 2010
Moore fills a hole after Johnson's balls dropped.
CapSea - August 2, 2010
I've got nothing...
CapSea - August 2, 2010
Here's some Moore
beastwarking - August 2, 2010
So, you feel Rob'd?
JAH - August 2, 2010
Rob Johnson had a shot to be the Mariners' catcher of the future?
This doesn’t seem to me to be a very promising future if so, considering that his realistic ceiling was somewhere in the Josh Bard/Tom Lampkin realm of “not a complete waste of bench space as a backup, but not very good as a starter”.
eponymous_coward - August 2, 2010
Trade for Montero!
fluffylamps - August 2, 2010
I'm fairly confident you're joking, but also probably not a catcher of the future for anyone.
I wonder what it’d take to pry Ramos away from the Nationals.
Jeff Nye - August 2, 2010
Actually, this probably skates a little too close to rosterbation, sorry.
I’m used to being able to delete my comments!
Please ignore.
Jeff Nye - August 2, 2010
DH of the future.
Thingray - August 2, 2010
I wonder if David Aardsma is a better pitcher than Matt Capps
seattlebruin - August 2, 2010
He reminds me of Bobby Jenks.
fluffylamps - August 2, 2010
Fat? Because they aren't similar pitchers at all.
lailaihei - August 2, 2010
Yes
fluffylamps - August 2, 2010
And they've got beards.
fluffylamps - August 2, 2010
They both have made-up sounding names?
Hopefulmsfan - August 2, 2010
Matt Capps seems like he should be a starting pitcher
Poochie - August 2, 2010
Maybe he meant Miguel Montero?
Slurvey - August 2, 2010
He's good too
Marinerfanjake - August 2, 2010
I'm pretty sure he meant Freddy Montero...
cfred - August 3, 2010
Mitsubishi Montero.
That’s about all we could get out of a Rob Johnson trade…
Lucas Cervi - August 3, 2010
HOOZAH!
Corco - August 2, 2010
Adam Moore has looked like shit this year, but I still like his upside and I think he's obviously the better choice over Rob.
I think his bat can play at the .310 wOBA level in the majors, and if we’re lucky he can be maybe be a .320 guy.
I really hope he’s good, because our system is devoid of catchers, and consistently average to above average catchers are not readily available.
lailaihei - August 2, 2010
The difference between a .310 wOBA and a .320 wOBA is like four runs over the course of a season
I think we can shoot higher than that for his upside.
seattlebruin - August 2, 2010
Isn't that like, 1% of our runs?
d0nkey - August 2, 2010
In my mind, he's like 40% chance to be at least .310, 15% to be at least .320 for the next few year.
.310 would put him slightly below average, assuming slightly below average defense.
.320 would put him slightly above average, assuming the same.
It’s possible he could reach higher, but his reasonable upside is basically Kurt Suzuki.
And I think about a 60% bust rate sounds about right.
lailaihei - August 2, 2010
I think there is a 82% chance that pulling numbers out of your ass is pointless.
abender20 - August 2, 2010
I bet if I could pull numbers out of my ass I could find an audience online to pay $19.95 a month.
Sec 108 - August 3, 2010
That's retarded.
I wouldn’t pay more than 15.
MT Olson - August 3, 2010
August 2, 2010 - the day the Rob Johnson passed ball counter moved to Tacoma.
Allen Wu - August 2, 2010
Another day in Mariners history.
fluffylamps - August 2, 2010
You, sir, are correct!
wyte_lightning - August 2, 2010
August 18, 2010 - the day that Ichiro played for the Mariners
seattlebruin - August 2, 2010
Another day in Mariners history.
seattlebruin - August 2, 2010
Now they're going to trade him.
Just to make you eat your words.
Hopefulmsfan - August 2, 2010
Yippee!
Eyeball Kid - August 2, 2010
WOOOOO
beastwarking - August 2, 2010
This is interesting, at minimum.
It could be Moore
ignacio - August 2, 2010
MOORE SOUNDS THE SAME AS MORE
Eyeball Kid - August 2, 2010
You should send the team a memo so they make sure to put that in next year's media pronounciation guide
seattlebruin - August 2, 2010
Think of all the songs they can play as his walk-up music.
Hopefulmsfan - August 2, 2010
Think of all the commercials he can do
Save Moore on car insurance!
Allen Wu - August 2, 2010
If he hits like he has at Tacoma we can go camping with him
and have s’mores
ignacio - August 2, 2010
Are you in the Boy Souts?
cause that sounds scary!
jbpalm - August 2, 2010
BULL. SHIT.
CapSea - August 2, 2010
I'm surprised but from Drayer, sounds like Rob isn't.
Johnson, who has struggled both offensively and defensively this year following three off season surgeries told me recently that the writing was on the wall. “I am not hitting and Adam deserves to come up,” he said after watching Josh Bard catch four out of five games on the last roadtrip. “If it happens I will go down there and work.”
wazzu93 - August 2, 2010
WHY DO YOU HAVE TO BE SO NICE ROB JOHNSON.
Slurvey - August 2, 2010
He's secretly plotting the death of Adam Moore.
Hopefulmsfan - August 2, 2010
I don't like Rob Johnson the player,
but that’s a pretty honest and nice thing of him to say.
marinerdan - August 3, 2010
He really is a nice guy.
SeaKoala - August 3, 2010
This should be Great News.
killer_ewok18 - August 2, 2010
Well that's nice.
Bearskin Rugburn - August 2, 2010
Awesome news, no more Rob Johnson!
Heydude - August 2, 2010
Sweet, now I can resurrect my catcher's interference drinking game!
Wonkish - August 3, 2010
Are you serous?
You can’t possibly drink very much with that game.
Patrick42 - August 3, 2010
With Adam Moore catching we can
seattlebruin - August 3, 2010
You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Lookout Landing to post a comment.